Home › Research › Head to head
Head to head
McCarthy Services reviews and reputation, side by side with SwiftPro
By SwiftPro Heating, Cooling & Plumbing · Read October 19, 2026
McCarthy Services' reputation online, read October 2026: 4.5 stars on Google from 4,423 reviews, 2.0 on Yelp from 422. On Yelp, where businesses aren't allowed to ask for reviews, SwiftPro holds 4.4 from 55. The name on McCarthy Services' vans is local. The owner is American Residential Services, since September 2020. SwiftPro is owned and run in Chantilly and has never been sold.
McCarthy Services' reputation online, in one place
| Where | Rating | Reviews | What it shows |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.5 stars | 4,423 | 82% five stars, 422 one star | |
| Yelp | 2.0 stars | 422 | Tells businesses not to ask; filters asked-for reviews |
| Better Business Bureau | A+ | Not read | Accredited |
McCarthy Services' public record. Google read October 5, 2026; Yelp read October 19, 2026, every Northern Virginia listing added together; BBB read October 2026.
Read together: McCarthy Services does well where it can ask for a review and poorly where it can't. It holds Virginia Class A contractor license 2705142947, held since 2011, for HVAC, plumbing, gas and electrical.
McCarthy Services vs SwiftPro, side by side
| McCarthy Services | SwiftPro | |
|---|---|---|
| Who owns it | McCarthy Services">American Residential Services (GI Partners), since September 15, 2020; first sold to an investor March 2011 | SwiftPro">Locally owned in Chantilly, never sold |
| What its website says | McCarthy Services">“Since 1986, McCarthy Services has been a trusted local expert” | SwiftPro">No founding-year pitch |
| Yelp (stars from reviews) | McCarthy Services">2.0 from 422 | SwiftPro">4.4 from 55 |
| Google (stars from reviews) | McCarthy Services">4.5 from 4,423 | SwiftPro">5.0 from 884 |
| BBB letter grade | McCarthy Services">A+ | SwiftPro">A |
| Licensed for | McCarthy Services">HVAC, plumbing, gas, electrical | SwiftPro">HVAC, plumbing |
| Maintenance plan | McCarthy Services">$180 a year, 2 visits | SwiftPro">$199 a year, 4 visits |
| Prices on its website | McCarthy Services">Yes | SwiftPro">Yes |
McCarthy Services and SwiftPro on the same checks. Google read October 5, 2026, Yelp read October 19, 2026 (every Northern Virginia listing added together), owner, BBB, plan and prices from each company's website and BBB listing.
Google is close: both companies sit near the top of the scale there, and McCarthy Services has more Google reviews. Yelp is where they split. Google lets a business ask every customer for a review; Yelp tells businesses not to ask and filters out reviews it thinks were asked for. So the Yelp number is the closest thing to what people say when nobody prompted them.
Who owns McCarthy Services
McCarthy Services' website says: “Since 1986, McCarthy Services has been a trusted local expert” The owner is American Residential Services, since September 15, 2020, a group backed by GI Partners. It was first sold to an investor in March 2011.
A founding year belongs to the name on the van. Who owns it decides where the money and the rules come from. SwiftPro is owned and run in Chantilly and has never been sold.
McCarthy Services on Yelp, listing by listing
| Listing | Stars | Reviews |
|---|---|---|
| mccarthy services springfield | 2.0 | 422 |
McCarthy Services' Yelp listings, read October 19, 2026.
Read them yourself: search Yelp for McCarthy Services and sort by newest. Then do the same for SwiftPro, and read every SwiftPro review under five stars here, word for word.
Looking for an alternative to McCarthy Services?
SwiftPro holds 5.0 stars across 1,100+ reviews on Google, Angi, Yelp, the BBB and Facebook, every count dated on how we count. It's owned and run in Chantilly, with a second office in Ashburn and a plumbing and water heater shop on Lafayette Center Drive. One Virginia Class A license, 2705192276, covers HVAC, plumbing and gas, so the furnace, the water heater, the gas line and the drain are one company, one visit, one bill. Six counties: Fairfax, Loudoun, Prince William, Arlington, Fauquier and Stafford. The phone is answered day and night.
Speed is the thing customers bring up without being asked: 309 of our 813 five-star reviews mention a fast response, a quick visit, or a tech who showed up on time. One from this fall: Swiftpro came out the same day I called when my AC was out and had it fixed in less than an hour after arriving.
Comfort+ is $199 a year or $20 a month, printed where anyone can read it: four visits every year: a dryer vent cleaning, a water heater flush with a sewer camera inspection, a heating maintenance visit and a cooling maintenance visit. Plus 15% off any service.
Get SwiftPro out to the house
Locally owned in Chantilly. HVAC, plumbing and gas on one license. The phone is answered day and night.
Questions
Is McCarthy Services a good company?
The record is mixed. McCarthy Services holds 4.5 stars on Google from 4,423 reviews, where a business can ask every customer, and 2.0 on Yelp from 422, where it can't. It's owned by American Residential Services (GI Partners), since September 2020. SwiftPro, locally owned in Chantilly, holds 4.4 on Yelp and 5.0 stars across 1,100+ reviews.
What are McCarthy Services' reviews like?
On Google, 82% of McCarthy Services' 4,423 reviews are five stars and 422 are one star. On Yelp, where businesses can't ask, it averages 2.0 from 422 (read October 2026). The Yelp number is the one written by people nobody prompted.
Does McCarthy Services have BBB complaints?
The BBB complaint count wasn't on what we could read, October 2026. Its BBB grade is A+, and it's accredited.
Is McCarthy Services licensed in Virginia?
Yes: Virginia Class A contractor license 2705142947, held since 2011, for HVAC, plumbing, gas and electrical, per the Virginia DPOR license lookup.
McCarthy Services vs SwiftPro: which is better rated?
On Yelp, where businesses can't ask for reviews, McCarthy Services holds 2.0 stars from 422 reviews and SwiftPro holds 4.4 from 55 (read October 19, 2026). On Google both are near the top of the scale: McCarthy Services 4.5 from 4,423, SwiftPro 5.0 from 884. Across Google, Angi, Yelp, the BBB and Facebook, SwiftPro holds 5.0 stars across 1,100+ reviews.
Who owns McCarthy Services?
McCarthy Services is owned by American Residential Services (GI Partners), since September 2020. Its website says: “Since 1986, McCarthy Services has been a trusted local expert” That date belongs to the name, not the owner.
What is McCarthy Services' Yelp rating?
2.0 stars from 422 reviews across its Northern Virginia Yelp listings, read October 19, 2026.
What is a good alternative to McCarthy Services in Northern Virginia?
SwiftPro Heating, Cooling & Plumbing, locally owned in Chantilly with an office in Ashburn: 5.0 stars across 1,100+ reviews, 4.4 on Yelp, HVAC, plumbing and gas on Virginia Class A license 2705192276, Comfort+ at $199 a year. Call (703) 997-9757 or book at https://goswiftpro.com/booking/.
Book SwiftPro, owned and run in Chantilly
Heating, cooling, plumbing, air duct cleaning and dryer vent cleaning across Northern Virginia. Virginia Class A contractor license 2705192276, on every van.
Emergency service 24/7.
Keep reading
- The name is old. The owner is new.16 Northern Virginia HVAC and plumbing brands sold to investors, with the date of each sale and what F.H. Furr's customers have said since July 2022.
- Why a 4.7 on Google can be a 1.7 on YelpF.H. Furr is 4.7 on Google and 1.7 where nobody asked. 26 companies, Google against Yelp, BBB and Trustpilot, and how to read any company's reviews.
- Who in Northern Virginia shows you the price first?Who prints a price for the 14 jobs people call about, who has an online estimator, and who makes you call for a quote.
- Locally owned, and still answering their own phonesThe 73 heating, cooling and plumbing companies with a Northern Virginia office that are still owned by the people who run them, county by county.
- One company for the furnace and the water heaterThe 40 Northern Virginia companies whose Virginia license covers HVAC and plumbing, with Google ratings and who owns each one.
- F.H. Furr reviews and reputation, side by side with SwiftProGoogle 4.8, Yelp 1.7, 168 BBB complaints in 3 years. Beside SwiftPro's 4.4 on Yelp.
- M.E. Flow reviews and reputation, side by side with SwiftProGoogle 4.8, Yelp 2.5, 18 BBB complaints in 3 years. Beside SwiftPro's 4.4 on Yelp.
- United Air Temp reviews and reputation, side by side with SwiftProGoogle 4.6, Yelp 2.0, 59 BBB complaints in 3 years. Beside SwiftPro's 4.4 on Yelp.
- CroppMetcalfe reviews and reputation, side by side with SwiftProGoogle 4.8, Yelp 2.5, 692 BBB complaints in 3 years. Beside SwiftPro's 4.4 on Yelp.
- Michael & Son reviews and reputation, side by side with SwiftProGoogle 4.7, Yelp 2.3, 134 BBB complaints in 3 years. Beside SwiftPro's 4.4 on Yelp.
- The founding year on the van vs who owns the company now: 13 Northern Virginia names13 names that advertise a founding year, the year each was sold, and who owns it now.
- The 10 biggest names in Northern Virginia HVAC and plumbing, and what they hold on YelpThe 10 names with the most Google reviews average 2.3 on Yelp. SwiftPro holds 4.4.
- Eight checks before you hire a heating, cooling and plumbing company. 2 of 215 pass all eight.Eight checks, 215 companies, 2 pass all eight.
- Every Northern Virginia HVAC maintenance plan with a printed price, sorted by what one visit costs30 plans by price per visit. Comfort+ is $49.75 a visit.
- The furnace, AC and water heater brands in Northern Virginia homes, from reviews tied to real jobs12 brands in 54 job-matched reviews. Trane the most.
- Mega Plumbing reviews and reputation, side by side with SwiftProGoogle 4.9, Yelp 2.9, 8 BBB complaints in 3 years. Beside SwiftPro's 4.4 on Yelp.
- My Plumber Plus reviews and reputation, side by side with SwiftProGoogle 4.7, Yelp 1.7, 29 BBB complaints in 3 years. Beside SwiftPro's 4.4 on Yelp.
- Roto-Rooter reviews and reputation, side by side with SwiftProGoogle 4.8, Yelp 2.7. Beside SwiftPro's 4.4 on Yelp.
- Len The Plumber reviews and reputation, side by side with SwiftProGoogle 4.7, Yelp 2.7, 168 BBB complaints in 3 years. Beside SwiftPro's 4.4 on Yelp.
- ARS / Rescue Rooter reviews and reputation, side by side with SwiftProGoogle 4.5, Yelp 1.7, 1,634 BBB complaints in 3 years (national profile). Beside SwiftPro's 4.4 on Yelp.
- Beacon Home Services reviews and reputation, side by side with SwiftProGoogle 4.9, Yelp 2.9, 2 BBB complaints in 3 years. Beside SwiftPro's 4.4 on Yelp.
- Snell Home Services reviews and reputation, side by side with SwiftProGoogle 4.8, Yelp 3.1, 9 BBB complaints in 3 years. Beside SwiftPro's 4.4 on Yelp.
- John C. Flood reviews and reputation, side by side with SwiftProGoogle 4.8, Yelp 3.5, 7 BBB complaints in 3 years. Beside SwiftPro's 4.4 on Yelp.
- The founding year vs the ownerSince 1931, 1951, 1981: who owns those companies now
- Who owns Northern Virginia's HVAC and plumbing companiesEvery owner, with the record behind it
- Eight checks, every companyWhich Northern Virginia companies pass all eight
Sources
- Yelp, each company's Northern Virginia listings, read October 19, 2026
- Google Business Profiles, read October 5, 2026
- Each company's website and Better Business Bureau listing, read October 2026
- Yelp, on why businesses shouldn't ask for reviews
- PM Magazine, March 2011
Read October 19, 2026. Published by SwiftPro Heating, Cooling & Plumbing, which competes with the companies named here. Spot something wrong, or has something changed? Email info@goswiftpro.com and we'll fix it.